Changing The Fumble Rule

Just out of New York:

“The NFL will look into the inadvertent whistle rule that required officials to give the ball back to Denver in the final seconds of Sunday’s game with San Diego.

League spokesman Greg Aiello said the NFL competition committee will look into the rule in the offseason, perhaps changing it as it did the ‘down by contact’ rule.

The play occurred with the Broncos at the Chargers 1-yard-line in the final minute. Denver quarterback Jay Cutler dropped back to pass, the ball slipped out of his hands, bounced off the grass and into the arms of San Diego linebacker Tim Dobbins.

Referee Ed Hochuli ruled it an incomplete pass. Replay ruled it a fumble, but it was spotted at the 10-yard line, where the ball hit the ground, and given to Denver because the rules did not permit possession to be awarded to San Diego because the whistle had blown.

Denver went on to score, convert a 2-point conversion and win 39-38.

Coach Norv Turner said he spoke with NFL officials Monday and that the Chargers sent in video of the plays in question.

‘As for things that occurred during the game, in my mind, they’re done,’ Turner said. ‘We sent the plays in to the league that we had in question. We expect to get a response back. Anything that we talk about or anything that is discussed in terms of any of the rules or any of the calls isn’t going to change the outcome of that game. That game is going to be 39-38, forever.’

Until March 2007, down by contact plays were not reviewable. That rule was changed so that they were reviewable, and if a fumble occurred even after the whistle blew, the team recovering it got possession.

‘Officials are held accountable for their calls. They are graded on every play of every game,’ Aiello said Monday. ‘Ed has been an outstanding official for many years, but he will be marked down for this call. Under our evaluation system, an official’s grades impact his status for potentially working the playoffs and ultimately whether or not he is retained.’”

There’s no doubt that the Broncos were lucky to come out of yesterday with a win. Culter clearly fumbled the ball, and the Chargers clearly recovered it. I would be extremely pissed if I were the Chargers, but you also have to know that rulings in sports are subjective. With that comes room for error. Ed Hochuli is an outstanding ref who has been called in for numerous playoff games and Super Bowls over the years. Maybe his success in the league is a result of his running habits.

Regardless, here is what Shaun Phillips of the Chargers wrote in his blog about the call.

 

Tags: Denver Broncos Ed Hochuli Jay Cutler Norv Turner San Diego Chargers Shaun Phillips Tim Dobbins

comments powered by Disqus