Broncos: 5 NFL legends that played just one season in Denver
Garrison Hearst, Running back
The No. 3 overall pick of the 1993 draft, Garrison Hearst had a roller-coaster kind of playing career that wound up in Denver.
Hearst was an absolute stud in college, nearly winning the Heisman Trophy after posting incredible numbers during his playing days in Georgia. He was drafted by the Cardinals and had a really slow start to his career before cracking 1,000 yards rushing in 1995.
After playing for one season with the Cincinnati Bengals, Hearst found the place where he would have his most success, San Francisco.
But that wouldn’t come easily.
After two huge seasons with the 49ers, including the 1998 season where he went over 1,500 yards and went to the Pro Bowl, Hearst suffered a severe ankle injury that cost him two full seasons of his career.
With doubts that he would ever play again, Hearst came back in 2001 and showed true heart in becoming the league’s Comeback Player of the Year. After two more decent seasons there, he signed with the Broncos as a free agent in 2004.
The Broncos never got any shred of that version of Hearst and he just wasn’t a good fit for the team.
Mike Shanahan saw him as a third-down back, but Hearst never settled into that role and finished the season with just 81 yards rushing on 20 carries. It was a quiet end to an otherwise impressive career, considering the circumstances.